Amex Platinum vs Chase Sapphire Reserve: which one pays for a hotel habit

The quick answer

Hold the Amex Platinum if you book luxury hotels directly and want Fine Hotels and Resorts, where breakfast for two, a room upgrade, a $100 property credit and a guaranteed 4pm checkout come with the rate. Hold the Sapphire Reserve if you are happy booking through Chase Travel, where the earning rate is higher.

The honest caveat is that both fees are only returned in full if you spend at lululemon, Peloton, DoorDash, Resy and the rest. For a reader who only travels, neither card is an obvious win, and the break even section below shows the arithmetic.

The fees, side by side

Both issuers now price these cards as a bundle of statement credits rather than as a travel card with a fee. The figures below are the published maximums, not what a normal person collects.

Hotel benefits, the only section most readers need

Amex wins this on structure. Fine Hotels and Resorts is open to Platinum and Centurion cardholders and states more than $550 of value per stay, made up of daily breakfast for two, a room upgrade when one is free, a $100 property credit and a guaranteed 4pm checkout. Those four things arrive with no hotel status of any kind, which is exactly what makes them useful at brands like Four Seasons that run no loyalty programme.

Below that sits the Hotel Collection, over 1,300 properties, which adds a $100 credit on any booking of two nights or more. Neither programme requires you to give up your normal rate, and the $600 hotel credit on the card can be spent on those bookings as it is paid, $300 at a time, twice a year.

Chase does something different. The Edit by Chase Travel is a hotel portfolio inside Chase's own booking channel, and the card carries a $500 credit to spend there plus 8x points on Chase Travel bookings including The Edit. Book direct with the hotel instead and the rate drops to 4x. That is the trade. Chase pays you more, on the condition that you book where Chase wants you to book.

For anyone who cares about being recognised at the property, the Amex route is the stronger one, because a Fine Hotels and Resorts reservation reaches the hotel as a preferred booking with benefits attached. A portal booking earning 8x is still a portal booking.

Hotel and lounge benefits compared

The rows that decide this comparison for a reader who books four or five luxury hotel stays a year.

What the credits are actually worth if you only travel

Add up everything Amex publishes and the total sails past the $895 fee. Then read the list again. The $300 Equinox credit, the $300 lululemon credit, the $200 Oura ring credit, the $155 Walmart Plus credit and the $300 digital entertainment credit are worth their face value to someone who already buys those things and nothing at all to someone who does not.

Chase is structured the same way. The $300 DoorDash credit, the $120 Peloton credit and the $300 StubHub and Viagogo credit are retail vouchers attached to a travel card. Strip them out and Chase is left with a $300 travel credit, a $500 Edit credit, $120 of Lyft and the lounge access.

So the fair question is not what the credits total. It is which credits a traveller collects by accident. On Amex that is the $600 hotel credit, the $200 airline fee credit and the $219 CLEAR Plus credit, and $200 of Uber Cash if car journeys are part of the trip. On Chase it is the $300 travel credit, the $500 Edit credit and $120 of Lyft.

Lounge access compared

Amex has the bigger network by a wide margin, at over 1,550 lounges. The Centurion Lounges are the reason people keep the card in the United States, and the ten Delta Sky Club visits a year matter if Delta is your airline. Priority Pass comes on enrolment rather than automatically, so it has to be activated.

Chase counters with quality rather than quantity. Sapphire Reserve gives Priority Pass on enrolment as well, and adds the Chase Sapphire Lounges, which let a cardholder bring two guests free. If you usually travel as a couple or a family, that guest allowance is worth more than a larger network you visit alone.

Neither card should be bought for lounges on their own. A standalone membership is cheaper, and I have priced that comparison separately.

The break even maths

Here is the worked example that matters on this site: a reader who books four luxury hotel stays a year, flies a few times, and uses none of the lifestyle credits.

On the Platinum, the fee is $895. The $600 hotel credit is collectable in full if the stays fall either side of the calendar year, since it is paid as up to $300 twice a year. Four Fine Hotels and Resorts stays collect four $100 property credits, so $400. The $200 airline fee credit is collectable if checked bags or seat fees are part of the year. That is up to $1,200 against $895, plus breakfast for two and a 4pm checkout on four stays, which is where the real value sits rather than in the dollar figures.

On the Sapphire Reserve, the fee is $795. The $300 travel credit is collectable against almost any trip. The $500 Edit credit is collectable only on Edit bookings, so it is worth $500 to someone happy to book through Chase and nothing to someone who insists on booking direct. That is $800 against $795 for the portal booker, and $300 against $795 for everyone else.

Be clear about what that shows. The Platinum clears its fee for this reader, but mostly by returning their own hotel spending to them through a narrower booking channel. The Sapphire Reserve only clears its fee if they book through Chase Travel. For a traveller who wants to book direct, keep flexibility and skip the lifestyle credits, neither card is obviously worth holding, and a no fee card plus a standalone lounge membership deserves a serious look.

Which to hold, and when to hold both

Hold the Platinum if the hotels you book are independents and brands without a loyalty programme, because Fine Hotels and Resorts is the only thing in this comparison that hands a guest with no status a breakfast, an upgrade and a late checkout. It is also the better card if you fly Delta or already pay for CLEAR Plus.

Hold the Sapphire Reserve if you are relaxed about the booking channel and want the points to compound, because 8x on Chase Travel and 4x on hotels booked direct is the stronger earning rate of the two, and the Sapphire Lounge guest allowance is the best family benefit here.

Holding both costs $1,690 a year before any credits, which only makes sense if the $600 Amex hotel credit, the $500 Edit credit and the $300 Chase travel credit are all genuinely spent, and the lifestyle credits on both cards are being used rather than admired. That is a narrow set of people.

Recommendation, in plain text until card partnerships are approved: for hotel value alone, apply for the American Express Platinum. For points and family lounge access, apply for the Chase Sapphire Reserve.

Questions readers actually ask

Keep reading

The rest of the card and lounge comparisons on this site.